Andy's Jamaican Oasis

4.4 (129 reviews )
$$
Restaurant
Takeout
Dine-in
Delivery
Lunch
+(6)

About Andy's Jamaican Oasis

Nestled on State Hwy 33 Trunk in Horicon, Wisconsin, Andy's Jamaican Oasis invites guests to experience a blend of Caribbean vibes and hearty fare. While known for its vibrant atmosphere and engaging hosts, the establishment has garnered attention for its exceptional fish fry, praised for its unique batter and generous portions. Diners have enjoyed the $1.50 Taco Tuesday special, although some guests have noted a lack of authentic Jamaican dishes, with tacos dominating the menu. Despite mixed service experiences, the friendly ambiance and value for money make Andy's a noteworthy culinary stop worth exploring.

Reviews (129) 4.4

  • Wild Elegance
    Jul 22,2025

    Cute little stop with great vibes and a wide variety of beverages. Service was a little less than desirable (we were clearly outsiders and not very welcomed) but drinks were strong.

  • Colin Raupp
    Jul 22,2025

    Stopped in for the fish fry. Best I’ve had in awhile. Battering on the fish was unique and when paired with the orange slice made for a great combination. French fry’s were so great I didn’t dare ruin them with ketchup. Everything was very reasonably priced. Will certainly be back.

  • Lisa Joyce
    Jul 22,2025

    I expected a Jamaican Oasis to serve Jamaican food. All they had was tacos, which were huge and very good, but deceptive naming of the establishment. Mary was our bartender, and was quite rude at first, but warmed up after a while.

  • Christopher Wolter
    Jul 22,2025

    Great atmosphere and Mary and Andy are very nice hosts. The food is amazingly good. $1.50 Taco Tuesday I especially like. I have become a regular on Tuesdays and Fridays for the Fish fry.

  • Life in the Shack
    Jul 22,2025

    Best fish fry I've ever had ,amazing batter and portion size.

  • Melissa Tesch
    Jul 22,2025

    Only had the fish fry here twice and totally worth the half hour drive and half hour wait for food. The breading is more like a fried chicken breading but it works! The fish was cooked perfectly, the homemade coleslaw was soooo yummy and the homemade potato salad is just as good. Definitely a place to try if youve never been there before!

  • Noah Abshire
    Jul 22,2025

    The people there are great the food is terrific and the prices are good as well I recommend you go there if you are in the neighborhood

Frequently Asked Questions

  • What are the popular dishes at Andy's Jamaican Oasis?

    The fish fry is a standout favorite, praised for its unique batter and delicious portion size. Tacos are also available and well-received by diners.

  • Does Andy's Jamaican Oasis accept reservations?

    Yes, the restaurant accepts reservations, making it easy for you to secure a table, especially during busy times.

  • Can I dine in or take out?

    You can enjoy your meal either by dining in the cozy atmosphere or opting for takeout if you're on the go.

  • What is the atmosphere like at the restaurant?

    The vibe is casual and cozy, making it a great spot for groups and solo diners alike. It's especially lively during Happy Hour!

  • Is parking available at Andy's Jamaican Oasis?

    Yes, there is free parking available both in the lot and on the street for guests visiting the restaurant.

Nearby Restaurants

Restaurant
Jameson's 1930 Inn

200 N Lake Ave, Crandon, WI 54520, United States

Restaurant
William Asian Food to go

1908 Tower Ave, Superior, WI 54880, United States

Restaurant
The Neighborhood Draft

5921 W Vliet St, Milwaukee, WI 53208, United States

Restaurant
Ella's Public House

W325S1777 Mickle Rd, Delafield, WI 53018, United States

Restaurant
Hop Dish & Vine

N2047 Spring St, Stockholm, WI 54769, United States

Restaurant
Camp Trippalindee

601 Langdon St, Madison, WI 53703, United States

Restaurant
Weatherwood Supper Club

12898 WI-32, Mountain, WI 54149, United States

Restaurant
countryside pub

8225 McHenry St, Burlington, WI 53105, United States

Restaurant
Barnacle Bud's

1955 S Hilbert St, Milwaukee, WI 53207, United States

Restaurant
Peters' Boyz Texas BBQ

100 S Birch St Suite C, Kimberly, WI 54136, United States

Are you the owner?

Claim this page to update business information and manage your presence.

Claim this page Claim this page